Epstein's Second Island, Zorro Ranch Part 3: New Mexico Asked & New York Said No
New Mexico opened an investigation in 2019. Federal prosecutors in New York told them to stand down. So the state stood down. The ranch sat. For seven years.
This is a part of the 49 Zorro Ranch Road Series
Part One | Victim Standalone | Part Two | Part 4
Your subscription truly helps share this work.
If you have tips related to the Zorro Ranch and Epstein Investigation, contact:
https://nmdoj.gov/get-help/epstein-zorro-tips/
When Jeffrey Epstein was arrested in July 2019, federal investigators moved fast. They swept across his Manhattan townhouse, the Palm Beach mansion, and Little Saint James — his infamous paedophile island. Hard drives, photographs, and evidence were recovered — enough to anchor the eventual case against Ghislaine Maxwell.
But, no federal warrant was ever sought for Zorro Ranch. Not then. Not ever.
A 2019 email from federal authorities to Epstein’s estate executors confirmed it plainly, agents had “not searched the New Mexico property.” Epstein died in his cell on August 10, 2019 and the ranch sat undisturbed — through the pandemic, through the trials, through all these long years.
Meanwhile, New Mexico wanted to act. Attorney General Hector Balderas launched a state investigation into alleged crimes at the ranch. That probe was shut down quickly — not because evidence was lacking, but because the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York asked New Mexico to halt, citing the risk of a “parallel investigation.” Balderas complied.
So, the FBI searched Epstein’s properties in New York, Florida, and the Virgin Islands. No search was ever conducted — by any agency, at any level — during the federal investigation or for the six years following Epstein’s death.
The ranch sat for six years and seven months.
It would not be searched for the first time until March 9, 2026.
Seven years of silence…finally broken.
But silence, it turns out, had a legal scaffolding.
A Santa Fe County Sheriff’s deputy talks with people at the Zorro Ranch near Stanley during a protest and memorial installation on Feb. 28. The New Mexico Department of Justice on Monday searched the ranch formerly owned by Jeffrey Epstein.
Eddie Moore/Journal
The Sex Offender Registry Exemption
Epstein pleaded guilty in Florida in 2008 to soliciting prostitution from an underage girl. That plea required him to register as a sex offender. And in New Mexico, he registered for exactly 2 days. A loophole in state law — based on the victim’s age in the specific Florida charge being over sixteen — allowed him to avoid the registry entirely. State officials later acknowledged they had “virtually no access and little knowledge” of what was happening at the ranch.
The Truth Commission is now specifically tasked with examining this exemption — and whether officials “looked the other way”.
For seven long years, the ranch held harrowing secrets behind a pad locked gate and a legal dodge. No warrant — no search. No registry — No eyes.
Until March 9, 2026.
Hector Balderas
New Mexico Office of the Attorney General
The Grazing Leases
Through the shell entity Cypress Inc., Epstein held state grazing leases on approximately 1159 to 1200 additional acres of public land surrounding the ranch — paying roughly $87,222 annually. The legal basis was agricultural use, but Epstein was not using the land for agriculture. State land officials later acknowledged they had “virtually no access and little knowledge” of the activities occurring on land they were renting to him. New Mexico Land Commissioner Stephanie Garcia Richard has described the state land as having functioned “almost as a buffer, a shield to hide what activity was occurring on the ranch.” The land grant gave the March 2026 search team a right of entry extending beyond the private property boundary.
Two Tips, No Action
In November 2019, an anonymous email arrived at Albuquerque radio host Eddy Aragon’s inbox. The sender claimed to be a former Zorro Ranch employee. The allegation: two foreign girls were buried somewhere in the hills outside the Zorro, on orders of Jeffrey and “Madam G” — widely interpreted as referring to Ghislaine Maxwell — after dying during rough sex. The sender claimed to possess seven videos from Epstein’s home, including material depicting minors, available for one Bitcoin (then approximately $8,000). Aragon says he knows the sender’s identity, shared it with the FBI, and personally visited the local FBI field office with the email.
A second communication — from a retired New Mexico State Police officer — flagged a suspicious barn on the property that appeared to contain a concealed incinerator. That report also reached the FBI. Both were filed but neither resulted in investigative action and neither prompted any search.
The FBI received two separate tips about potential physical evidence at Zorro Ranch in 2019 — one alleged buried bodies and one alleged a concealed incinerator. Neither prompted any investigative response. Again, the ranch was not searched.
Survivor memorial — flowers and candles at Zorro Ranch gate, International Women’s Day, March 8, 2026
Eddie Moore/Journal
February 2026: The Investiation Re-Opens
On February 16, 2026, the New Mexico House of Representatives unanimously passed House Resolution 1, creating the bipartisan Epstein Truth Commission. It is chaired by Rep. Andrea Romero and includes Rep. Marianna Anaya, former FBI agent Rep. William “Bill” Hall, and prosecutor Rep. Andrea Reeb. The commission has $2 million in funding — drawn from a 2022 settlement New Mexico reached with Epstein’s banks — and must file an initial report by July 31, 2026, and a final report by year’s end.
Three days later, on February 19, AG Raúl Torrez announced the NMDOJ was reopening its criminal investigation citing “revelations outlined in the previously sealed FBI files.” The NMDOJ launched a digital tip line for credible information about Epstein’s activities in New Mexico. You can view that here: https://nmdoj.gov/get-help/epstein-zorro-tips/
March 9, 2026: The First Search
On the morning of March 9, 2026 NMDOJ investigators, New Mexico State Police, and K9 units from the Sandoval County Sheriff’s Office entered Zorro Ranch for the first time under any law enforcement authority. The property’s current owners — the Huffines family — cooperated.
Construction at the property, begun by new owner Don Huffines in connection with plans to convert the ranch to a Christian retreat, had been ordered to stop by Santa Fe County officials due to lack of permits. A former FBI agent on the Truth Commission had raised concerns that ongoing renovation could compromise physical evidence.
The property is now named Rancho de San Rafael. The search results have not been publicly disclosed. The commission’s July 2026 initial report is expected to address findings.
The Massacre Of The Innocence
Epstein surrounded himself with art. At Zorro Ranch, paintings and sculptures lined the main house, the guest quarters, and the long corridors connecting them. Former visitors described a private collection heavy with religious imagery, classical nudes, and darker themes — often hung without explanatory plaques or provenance.
Massacre of the Innocence - EFTA00553278
Among those works was a piece titled Massacre of the Innocence. A photograph of the artwork has since surfaced, though its creator and date remain unknown. According to sources familiar with the ranch’s layout — whose accounts remain unverified — the painting hung in Epstein’s private study, a room off the master suite that guests were rarely, if ever, allowed to enter. Others place it along the upstairs hallway leading to the bedrooms used by young visitors.
The title is not incidental. It echoes the biblical slaughter of children — and, more darkly, the core allegations that have followed Epstein’s New Mexico property for years. Whether Epstein chose the piece for its aesthetic, its irony, or its confession is unknown. But the Truth Commission has taken note of its presence.
The painting was not seized in March 2026. The ranch’s current owners — the Huffines family, who bought the property in 2023 and renamed it Rancho de San Rafael — have not commented on its current location.
‘Epstein has been dead for years. Zorro Ranch has changed ownership. Physical evidence may no longer exist, and the statute of limitations has likely run on many potential offenses. These are real obstacles, and survivors deserve to hear them stated plainly.’
— New Mexico AG Raúl Torrez
Truth is, this work takes all of us.
If this investigation has been useful to you — if it gave you something to think about, something to share, something to act on — consider supporting Last Page First. Independent investigative journalism doesn’t have institutional backing behind it. It has the readers ♥
Have a tip? A lead you want to share?
This work is entirely reader supported. No grants, no advertisers, no editorial board — just primary documents and the time it takes to read them. If you want to keep this going, donating is the most direct way to help. Thank you.
Sources
New Mexico Department of Justice — investigation reopened statement, February 19, 2026
New Mexico Department of Justice — search statement, March 9, 2026
Epstein Files — Eddy Aragon anonymous tip email, November 2019 (DOJ EFTA release) EFTA01250229
Epstein Files — Massacre of the Innocence EFTA00553278
ABC News: ‘Why are authorities finally searching Epstein’s ranch in New Mexico?’ March 2026
CNN: ‘New Mexico authorities search Zorro Ranch,’ March 10, 2026
Time: ‘Epstein’s Zorro Ranch Searched in Criminal Investigation,’ March 10, 2026
Source New Mexico: ‘NM Department of Justice, police search former Zorro Ranch,’ March 10, 2026
Christian Science Monitor: ‘What happened at Epstein’s Zorro Ranch?’ April 3, 2026
NBC News: ‘New Mexico approves comprehensive probe of Epstein’s Zorro Ranch,’ February 17, 2026
New Republic: ‘Epstein’s New Mexico Horror House Will Finally Be Investigated,’ March 2026
2nd Life Media Alamogordo: ‘New Mexico Launches Two-Pronged Investigation,’ March 1, 2026
WSWS: ‘New Mexico conducts first-ever search of Epstein’s Zorro Ranch,’ March 12, 2026
The Estate had people living on the ranch after Epstein died. This incident was in 2022, three years after Epstein died. “Mystery over Epstein’s $24M Zorro Ranch deepens as estate threatened with prosecution after staff pointed GUN at hiker.” 
https://www.the-sun.com/news/5861503/epstein-zorro-ranch-prosecution-gun-hiker/